Self-Love vs. Self-Love

In the last year and a half or so, I’ve thought a good deal about the concept of ‘self-esteem’.  As a handwriting analyst, this is one of the easiest things to spot in someone’s personality on paper, and whether it’s low or high defines the writer in hugely significant ways.  High self-esteem means high goals, a certain fearlessness, confidence in one’s abilities, and it strengthens other personality traits.  Low self-esteem means a fear of failure, hesitation in taking risks, an irrational sense of one’s own limitations and imperfections, and it spreads insecurity throughout the whole personality.

Does the term ‘self-esteem’ strike you as one of those phrases thrown around by soft psychologists who try to fix everyone’s problems by telling them to “believe in themselves” or other such fluff?  It struck me this way to a certain degree before I began to study the differences between ‘ego’ and ‘self-esteem’.  Basically, what I want to demonstrate is that ‘ego’ is oneself as oneself, whereas ‘self-esteem’ is oneself as a human being.

I just recently finished reading through C.S. Lewis’ collection of essays, God in the Dock, and a few days ago, one of the shorter pieces really made an impact on me.  The title of the essay is Two Ways With the Self, and in it Lewis explains the contrast between two types of self-love.  He does this much better than I can, so I’m going to quote him a bit:

Now, the self can be regarded in two ways.  On the one hand, it is God’s creature, an occasion of love and rejoicing; now, indeed, hateful in condition, but to be pitied and healed.  On the other hand, it is that one self of all others which is called I and me, and which on that ground puts forward an irrational claim to preference.  This claim is to be not only hated, but simply killed…(p. 194)

We all know that we’re instructed to “love your neighbor as yourself”, and wouldn’t you agree that this would not mean much for our neighbor if we had an overall low and critical view of ourselves?  Yes, we are imperfect now and there are always many things to improve upon in our lives, personalities, etc.; but we also know that we’re supposed to love one another without judging, without nit-picking, but instead with compassion and encouragement.  If our neighbors are to receive kind and loving treatment from us, we must first deal with ourselves in the same way.

What Lewis calls “an irrational claim to preference” is the self-love completely opposite of this.  When we love ourselves primarily because we are ourselves and for no other reason, our main motivators become selfishness, greed, pride.  When we realize that this type of ‘high view’ of ourselves isn’t shared by others or we are let down by life in general, we fall apart and, failing to nurture and show compassion to ourselves, we become unable to be helpful to others as well.  In fact, being down on ourselves makes us more likely to wish misfortune on others.  Lewis describes this spreading of a low view or ourselves onto others:

The other kind of self-hatred, on the contrary hates selves as such.  It begins by accepting the special value of the particular self called me; then, wounded in its pride to find that such a darling object should be so disappointing, it seeks revenge, first upon that self, then on all.  Deeply egoistic, but now with an inverted egoism, it uses the revealing argument, ‘I don’t spare myself’…(p. 194-195)

In sum, when we love ourselves as God loves us, daily putting to death our many failings yet constantly forgiving and encouraging, we will have a sense of self-esteem which goes hand in hand with humility.  Then we will be equipped to love others as ourselves, with exhortation and consolation.  One last quote:

The wrong asceticism torments the self: the right kind kills the selfness.  We must die daily: but it is better to love the self than to love nothing, and to pity the self than to pity no one (p. 195).

All the best,



5 thoughts on “Self-Love vs. Self-Love

  1. Jack Bradley says:

    Very helpful distinctions, Allie. “love ourselves primarily because we are ourselves and for no other reason” vs. “love ourselves as God loves us”

    Could you follow up on this: “a healthy balance between humility and self-esteem” I understand your equating the second type of love with humility. Are you equating the first type of love with the concept of ‘self-esteem’?


    • Allie B. says:

      Thank you for asking for a follow-up on that sentence. I actually did not mean that at all and have re-written that section. I guess that’s what happens when I try to make sense right before I go to bed. :)

      I agree completely with Lewis when he says (right at the beginning of the essay I’ve been quoting):

      “We must not explain this apparent contradiction by saying that self-love is right up to a certain point and wrong beyond that point. The question is not one of degree…One [type] is wrong from the beginning and the other right to the end…”

  2. Robin says:

    This is a good way to explain the difference. This might be slightly tangental, but something I’ve often thought about is how often we are told that we are “okay just the way we are.” It seems like this can have two completely different meanings, depending on who is saying it. When many people say it, I think they are trying to deny their sin nature.

    But sometimes, it is absolutely true that we need to embrace our personality as being what God wanted. It is okay for one person to be quiet and another loud, because God made them both that way. I think a lot of Christians throw the baby out with the bathwater in an attempt to counter error of validating their sin. But then a lot of Christians end up with low “self-esteem,” because they lose their faith that God made them the way they are and actually likes them that way!

    • Allie B. says:

      Thanks for the good thoughts, Robin. I’d like to write a bit on that topic as well. N.T. Wright’s new book “After You Believe” taught me sooo much in this area, and I highly recommend it. By the way, I miss you! You should come back and visit again. :)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s